发表于 2025-04-10 15:58 IP属地:未知
查看 9.6W | 回复 10
分别问了两个不同AI一个相同的问题,你觉得哪个回答得好?
问题:Is it legal to leave my 14 year old son in a hotel alone when traveling in Hong Kong
甲ai的回答:
Based on the information found, it is potentially illegal to leave your 14-year-old son alone in a hotel room when traveling in Hong Kong.
Here's why:
Offences Against the Person Ordinance (Cap. 212): Section 27 of this ordinance makes it an offence for a person over the age of 16 years who has the custody, charge, or care of any child or young person under the 1 age of 16 years to wilfully assault, ill-treat, neglect, abandon, or expose such child or young person in a manner likely to cause unnecessary suffering or injury to health. 2 ?
1.
familyclic.hk
familyclic.hk
2.
OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON ORDINANCE - Historical Laws of Hong Kong Online
oelawhk.lib.hku.hk
Interpretation of Neglect: While the law doesn't specify an exact age at which a child can be left unattended, leaving a 14-year-old alone in a hotel room could be interpreted as neglect depending on the circumstances, such as the duration, the maturity of the child, and any potential risks involved.
Case Example: A report from The SUN HK mentions a case in 2017 where a mother was arrested for leaving her 15-year-old daughter alone at a restaurant for five hours, even though the girl was unharmed. This indicates that authorities in Hong Kong take the supervision of individuals under 16 seriously.
In conclusion, while there isn't a definitive law stating the exact age a child can be left alone in Hong Kong, it is prudent to consider it potentially illegal to leave your 14-year-old son unattended in a hotel room. This could be viewed as neglect under the Offences Against the Person Ordinance, especially for an extended period.
It is highly recommended to ensure adult supervision for your 14-year-old son while in Hong Kong to avoid any potential legal issues and, most importantly, to ensure his safety and well-being. If you need to leave him alone for a short period, it would be wise to assess his maturity level and the safety of the hotel environment carefully. For specific legal advice, it would be best to consult with a legal professional in Hong Kong.
乙ai的回答:
In Hong Kong, there is no specific law that states a minimum age at which a child can be left alone, including in a hotel. However, parents or guardians are expected to ensure the safety and well-being of their children under Section 26 of the Offences Against the Person Ordinance (Cap. 212), which relates to child neglect.
Key Considerations:
Maturity & Responsibility – If your 14-year-old is responsible and capable of staying alone (e.g., knows emergency procedures, can handle basic needs), it may be acceptable.
Hotel Policy – Many hotels require guests under 18 to be accompanied by an adult. Check with the hotel beforehand.
Local Norms – Hong Kong is generally safe, but leaving a minor alone in an unfamiliar place could raise concerns if they encounter issues (e.g., getting lost, medical emergencies).
Legal Risk – If something goes wrong (e.g., injury, disturbance), authorities could investigate for neglect.
Recommendation:
If your son is mature and the hotel allows it, leaving him for short periods (e.g., a few hours) may be fine.
For overnight stays, consider hiring a babysitter or using a supervised teen program if available.
Ensure he has a phone, emergency contacts, and knows how to reach you.
Would you like help finding family-friendly hotels in Hong Kong?